Point/Counterpoint: Governor’s State of the State address and Democrats’ response

By Rob Nikolewski on January 21, 2014
Print This Post Print This Post

By Rob Nikolewski │ New Mexico Watchdog

SANTA FE  – The 30-day legislative kicked off Tuesday with citing a familiar list of her favorite priorities — such as education reform and measures aimed at boosting New Mexico’s lagging economy — but the response from Democrats bluntly called her 47-minute speech “gimmicky.”

Here are some quotes from the respective speeches delivered by Martinez to a joint session of the Legislature and state , who addressed reporters and Democratic supporters in a committee room about a half hour after the governor spoke:

“GIMMICKY BITS AND PIECES”: State Sen. William Soules, D-Las Cruces, responds to the State of the State Address. NM Watchdog photo.

Martinez:

“Our focus must be on two of the most pressing issues – jobs and education.”

Soules:

“We don’t need gimmicky bits and pieces, where you can cherry-pick the data.”

Martinez:

“Washington remains a mess … We cannot bank on that changing, not anytime soon … we should fight equally hard for a more diverse economy.”

Soules:

“If we don’t deal with poverty … then we will always be down near the bottom.”

Martinez: “We’re doing better fighting the headwinds from Washington, but I’m the first to say that we have a lot of work left to do.”

Soules: “Where are the jobs? We continue to be ranked below our neighboring states … The supply-side economics of the past did not work and does not work.”

Martinez:

“We should expect a return on our education dollars … If a child can’t read by the end of the third grade, it’s far more compassionate to give them an extra year of help to catch up, rather than simply passing them on … Let’s not play games. Let’s finally end social promotion.”

Soules:

“I’m a teacher, an educator, I teach statistics. I get tired of hearing how third-graders are four times more likely (to not graduate if they can’t read by the third grade) … She uses false and misleading statistics to make it sound scary.”

“LET’S NOT PLAY GAMES”: Gov. Susana Martinez delivers her State of the State Address. NM Watchdog photo.

Martinez:

“We should support our teachers by providing them with thorough and fair evaluations.”

Soules:

“Merit pay does not work in a system like education.”

Martinez:

“Last year, we saw our graduation rate rise from 63 percent to 70 percent … Let’s continue to choose reform over the status quo.”

Soules on legislation offered by Democrats for a to pay for early childhood education programs:

“We need to do that. We can’t wait.”

Martinez:

“Education spending is now above pre-recession levels, the highest in state history. My budget calls for $100 million more.”

Soules:

“Doubling an insufficient amount does not get you to a sufficient amount … (We call for) local control, so that local school boards have control of those education dollars.”

Martinez:

“I’m once again asking this Legislature to repeal the dangerous law that gives driver’s licenses to illegal immigrants.”

Soules:

“The governor is using this issue as a political wedge to separate people by class and to scare people … 10 additional states have begun to issue driver’s licenses to the undocumented.”

Martinez:

“New Mexico is striving to be a business-friendly state. The message is critically important in a global economy. We all know that businesses have choices, and they will locate and grow where they are treated fairly.”

Soules on Democrats proposing a constitutional amendment to raise the state’s minimum wage:

“Modest raises to the minimum wage does not hurt jobs. Basic economics tells us when money moves, the economy improves … It’s time now to pass a living wage.”

Martinez:

“New Mexico’s water infrastructure is in a state of crisis … I’m asking that we invest 60 percent of our capital dollars on critical water projects throughout New Mexico.”

Soules:

“Gov. Martinez has not included the Legislature in how those 60 percent of capital outlay dollars will be spent. She instead says, trust me … (She is) trying to work around us.”

Martinez:

“With great challenges come great opportunities. To seize these opportunities, we must come together.”

Soules:

“We need someone who will lead and govern, not play politics.”

Contact Rob Nikolewski at and follow him on Twitter @robnikolewski

Posted under Capitol Report.
Tags: ,

2 Comments For This Post So Far


  1. 9:07 pm on January 21st, 2014

    And Soules believes that a kid that can’t read in the third grade should continue on and become so far behind they he may never catch up-thus another drop out? When I was in school, if you did not make the grade, you stayed behind until you could keep up. A bored child or a baffled child will not do well in school. The bored child has the better chance of continuing on and graduating with an education. The baffled child who graduates but is NOT educated will never make it in this world. I don’t know where some of these ideas come from to slide kids through school without being educated-can’t read or write and math, who needs that? No wonder this country is falling behind the rest of the world. Give it another 20 years and it will be a third world country at the rate things are going.

  2. James A. McClure
    2:50 pm on January 23rd, 2014

    I wonder where they get the notion that merit pay cannot work in education? After all, it’s never been tried to a significant degree. Perhaps the belief that all teachers are top performers comes from Garrison Keillor’s Lake Wobegon, “where all the children are above average,”

Leave a Reply

CAPTCHA Image
Refresh Image
*

Powered by