New Mexico Watchdog’s Top 10 stories of 2013
Print This Post
By Rob Nikolewski │ New Mexico Watchdog
SANTA FE — New Mexico taxpayers this past year saw little good, plenty of bad and a whole lot of ugly.
A review of the Top 10 stories covered and uncovered by shows a parade of bad behavior and wasted money in the Land of Enchantment.
But to show we’re not overly cynical, we give credit where due. After all, in 2013 the New Mexico Legislature managed to do something that most other states have not: It passed state pension reform.
That kicks off our Top 10 list:
10) The Pension Fix
State-sponsored pension plans across the country are hemorrhaging money. Illinois, for example, is facing a , which has the state’s credit rating because the government worker retirement system’s debt is “unsustainable.”
Heading into last January’s legislative session, New Mexico faced a $12 billion hole in its Public Employee Retirement Association and Educational Retirement Board pension plans. But led by state Sen. George Muñoz, D-Gallup, who even garnered support from the state employees union, a pension fix wended its way through both chambers and was signed Republican Gov. Susana Martinez.
Critics on the left say the legislation was too draconian, and fiscal hawks say it didn’t go far enough but the state Supreme Court last week turned back a challenge from disgruntled retirees and upheld the law. New Mexico has its problems but in this instance, it distinguished itself by addressing a looming crisis other states have ignored.
9) Drunk or Stoned On The Job? No Problem!
Don’t get too excited about legislative efforts, though. A number of common-sense measures didn’t survive the session, including a bill introduced by Rep. Dennis Roch, R-Texico, to clarify language in the Workers Compensation Act.
The bill stemmed from a case in which a city sanitation worker in Las Cruces fell off a garbage truck and injured his head, wrists and a hip. Some , the worker was found to have a blood-alcohol level of .12, well above the .08 limit in New Mexico for being legally drunk. But he still received of his workman’s compensation claim, which cost taxpayers about $90,000. Roch’s bill was tabled on a party line vote, with one Democrat telling New Mexico Watchdog the legislation was “kind of overbearing and punitive.”
8) Social Media Meltdowns
We’re 14 years into the 21st century, so one would think just about everyone would know what goes out over the Internet stays on the Internet. Forever.
But a Republican political operative and the head of Albuquerque Public Schools committed blunders that left people shaking their heads. In April, , the executive director of the Bernalillo County Republican Party, went on Facebook during a public hearing on raising the minimum wage and called one liberal activist a “radical bitch.” Kush apologized, was suspended and eventually stepped down from his post.
Then, in November, APS Superintendent Winston Brooks nearly lost his for going on Twitter and comparing the female secretary-designate of the New Mexico Public Education Department to livestock. “Moo, Moo, Oink, oink!!” the 61-year-old Brooks wrote in a message to a TV reporter while he complaining about being bored at a school board meeting. An uproar ensued, Brooks was suspended for three days and took down his Twitter page. It’s still down today.
7) Tuition Sticker Shock
The cost of a college education is steadily rising, and a New Mexico Watchdog investigation showed that in-state tuition and fees have gone up 169 percent at the University of New Mexico in the past 15 years.
In the just about same space of time, in-state tuition and fees have gone up by more than 120 percent at five of the six publicly funded universities in the state.
“We are finding a growing part of our labor force who go to college and are ending up unable to get jobs in professional, technical and managerial levels,” said economist of Ohio University, who has been studying the rising costs of a college education across the country. “We’ve just come out a paper showing that there are 115,000 janitors across the country with bachelor’s degrees.” That won’t make paying off those student loans any easier.
6) Disability Spike
The rising number of Americans receiving disability payments has skyrocketed.
In June, New Mexico Watchdog took a look at the numbers for New Mexico and learned the state has outpaced the country in the rate of people receiving benefits. Our review showed that between 2003 and 2011 (the most recent year available), New Mexico experienced an increase of 58.7 percent, compared to a 39.5 percent increase in national numbers. “We are not in position to say why the numbers have fluctuated 60 percent,” a spokeswoman for the Social Security Administration told us.
Then, less than a month later, New Mexico Watchdog learned that by the own figures, the national is on a path to go broke in fewer than three years. “This thing is a quite a mess,” said , a budget analyst for the . “I’m not aware of any plans for substantive reform.”
5) Manny Aragon Released
This summer, New Mexico Watchdog heard rumblings that Manny Aragon was in line for an early release from prison. On Dec. 5, it happened.
The former state Senate Pro Tem, once considered among the most powerful political figures in state history, was released from a federal facility in Florence, Colo., six months ahead of schedule. Instead of going to a halfway house, Aragon is free to live in his over-the-top “castle” in Albuquerque’s South Valley, where he will be monitored until early May 2014.
In 2008 Aragon pleaded guilty to charges of fraud and conspiracy for his role in a scheme to defraud the state out of nearly $4.4 million in building the Bernalillo County Metropolitan Courthouse. He’s been ordered to pay restitution, of which Aragon is using part of his state-funded pension to pay off. Aragon receives $27,311 per year, which totals more than $204,000 since 2005.
The Legislature has since passed a law forcing public officials to forfeit at least part or all of their pay and pensions should they be convicted of felonies connected to their duties in office, but it was not retroactive to cases such as Aragon’s.
4) Convicted Mayor Gets Pension
Just a couple of weeks after the Aragon story broke, New Mexico Watchdog learned of a similar story concerning the former mayor of the New Mexico border town of Columbus. Eddie Espinoza was released early from federal prison after getting convicted of smuggling firearms to Mexico. NM Watchdog learned that despite the conviction, Espinoza still receives a taxpayer-supported pension of $1,387.89 a month — which works out to nearly $17,000 a year.
Like Aragon, Espinoza was convicted before the Legislature passed its anti-corruption bill.
3) Tale of the Iguana Snatcher
If, say, a member of a high school basketball team got nabbed stealing something worth thousands of dollars, you can bet the player would get kicked off the team.
But when a member of Pojoaque Valley School Board was caught on security video absconding with a bronze sculpture of an iguana from outside a bar at the Buffalo Thunder Resort and Casino, he kept his job on the board.
After drinking one night in late September, Jon Paul Romero grabbed the iguana on his way out the door. After detectives found the iguana in Romero’s living room, the school board member said he swiped the statue — estimated to be worth up $5,000 — as a “prank.” Despite having a history of drunk driving arrests, Romero was not charged with theft. Instead, the Santa Fe District Attorney placed Romero in a pre-prosecution program, where non-violent offenders can avoid conviction by meeting certain requirements.
Even though the story was splashed across media outlets across the state, Romero refused to step down from the school board, which sets policy for students, teachers and administrators in the district. “It’s a personal matter and it has nothing to do with the board,” Romero told New Mexico Watchdog. The board said it had no authority to demand Romero’s resignation and issued a mild reprimand, saying it “does not condone the actions of Board Member Romero.”
So Romero is still on the board while the iguana is back at the bar.
Here’s the security video of the iguana-napping:
2) Conventioneering on the Taxpayers’ Dime
is one of the biggest liberal political conventions of the year, drawing progressives from all over the country for seminars with titles such as “Using Republicans’ Own Words to Shut that Whole Thing Down.”
So imagine the New Mexico Watchdog’s surprise to see that the Rio Arriba County Commission approved all expenses for two county employees to attend the five-day convention in San Jose, Calif. Lauren Reichelt, the county’s director for Health and Human Services, told NM Watchdog she lobbied the commission to send her to NetRoots Nation simply because “it’s the very best conference for using social media, for working with communities … It isn’t for the political stuff.”
But it just so happens that Reichelt is the vice chair of the county’s Democratic Party and . The NM Watchdog story produced a storm of controversy in Rio Arriba County, prompting an editorial in the local newspaper that said, “To use taxpayer dollars to fully fund a trip for such blatant and scathing political reasons is a gross misuse of power.”
Reichelt and the other county employee still attended the convention, ut five months later the county manager announced the commission won’t approve any more trips to NetRoots Nation.
1) The Great Grandma and the IRS
The scandal surrounding the allegedly targeting conservative political groups had a long reach — all the way to an 83-year-old great-grandma in Albuquerque.
One of the aggrieved parties was the , which said the IRS besieged them with questions for four years about the group’s nonprofit status. One of the queries from the IRS centered on the group’s relationship to “Marianne Chiffelle’s Breakfasts.”
New Mexico Watchdog started digging and discovered that “Marianne Chiffelle’s Breakfasts” is not a restaurant chain but a great-grandmother and survivor of a World War II internment camp in the Pacific who organizes informal 9 a.m. meetings for members of the at the Golden Corral on Eubank and Central Avenue in Albuquerque.
“I was surprised about the whole thing,” said the real, live Marianne Chiffelle, who readily admitted she’s active in state GOP politics and hands out patriotic coloring books to kids in the area.
Chiffelle told New Mexico Watchdog she understands the IRS has a job to do but was bothered by the agency’s drawing her into the investigation — and won’t back down from expressing her views about the government and politics.
“Don’t cut me short,” Chiffelle said. “I was a prisoner of war in the second World War. If the Japanese (military in World War II) couldn’t kill me, no one else can. That’s my philosophy. If something is unfair, I will fight to the death.”
Here’s our Watchdog interview with the feisty great-grandma:
Contact Rob Nikolewski at and follow him on Twitter @robnikolewski
Posted under News.
Tags: Cato Institute, Daily Kos, Dennis Roch, Eddie Espinoza, Facebook, George Munoz, Internal Revenue Service, Jon Paul Romero, Lauren Reichelt, Manny Aragon, Marianne Chiffelle, Net Roots Nation, New Mexico Watchdog, pension reform, Richard Vedder, Rio Arriba County Commission, Social Security Administration, Steve Kush, Susana Martinez, Tad DeHaven, Twitter, University of New Mexico, Winston Brooks
3:24 pm on December 25th, 2013
You did a great job reporting the New Mexico News this year. I just want to take the time to thank you and hope you and yours are having a Very Merry Christmas, and wish you many more.
4:14 pm on December 25th, 2013
Merry Christmas and hope you and you family have a wonderful 2014.
5:27 pm on December 25th, 2013
Keep up the good work… you fight the good fight… Merry Christmas
8:48 pm on December 26th, 2013
The top story is a “scandal” that has fizzled out despite Republicans wasting days and days of time in Washington on it.
Which makes sense, since New Mexico Watchdog got its big break from a false story by Jim Scarantino. Good to see the tradition continues with Rob Nikolewski — stories that overpromise, underdeliver and are proven false.
Did the Franklin Center tell you to write that story? How much editorial control does the Franklin Center have on your stories, since these seem coordinated with other Watchdog stories?
2:34 pm on December 29th, 2013
If you don’t like NM Watchdog, that’s fine and dandy.
But to say that Jim Scarantino’s stimulus story was false is flat out wrong. In 2009, Scarantino correctly pointed out that the Obama administration’s recovery.org website bragged about dollars spent and jobs saved and/or created in New Mexico’s 22nd and 35th Congressional Districts.
Scarantino pointed out that New Mexico has just three congressional districts in the entire state. https://newmexico.watchdog.org/454/obama-administration-reports-25-jobs-saved-by-stimulus-in-nms-22nd-congressional-district-and-thats-not-the-only-whopper/
The story received national coverage. A national writer for AP looked into it and reported, “THE FACTS: Scarantino’s original report was correct, and his analysis was the latest discovery of problems in the massive database of stimulus spending.”
Some concluded that perhaps the money never reached states like New Mexico or was misspent but Scarantino never reported that.
Furthermore, Jonathan Karl of ABC News also reported a similar story:
And the Annenberg Foundation, known to be left-of-center, confirmed the stories that grew out of Scarantino’s report on the foundation’s factcheck.org site, writing, “We’ve been skeptical in the past about the Obama adminstration’s claims of having ‘created or saved’ hundreds of thousands of jobs when in fact the economy was losing jobs. Those claims were just estimates. Now the administration is purporting to count real jobs — and we’re still finding reason to be skeptical.”
So, contrary to what you say, Scarantino’s story was correct and you are wrong.
And, no, the Franklin Center — nor anybody else — does not dictate my stories.
10:59 pm on December 29th, 2013
Rob, you’re lying again.
Scarantino wrote, “Other fictional New Mexico Congressional Districts receiving stimulus money ”
Yet you say that Scarantino didn’t say money was misspent. He say sit went to fake districts — when it clearly did not, as others later reported. Scarantino never fixed this mistake.
Why didn’t you quote this part of that AP story: “The problem is real. Its significance is overstated, and in some instances, fabricated.”
The ABC story just highlights that they actually reached out to find out why it happened — unlike the hatchet job that Scarantino put out.
It’s really ironic that rebuttals of what you wrote are included in the very things that you link to.
Another reason to never trust Rob Nikolewski and his Right Wing agenda.
10:54 am on December 30th, 2013
You are tiresome. The AP story did NOT say the Scarantino article was fabricated.
It said others may have overstated the problem or even fabricated some instances but did NOT attribute that to Scarantino.
Again, the definitive quote from AP: “Scarantino’s original report was correct, and his analysis was the latest discovery of problems in the massive database of stimulus spending.”
9:45 pm on January 15th, 2014
Ricard C is, I believe, Richard Cooley, a delegate to the last Dem National Convention, an Albuquerque ward leader and a blind partisan who lacks the integrity to identify himself. He’s been at this for five years. Thanks for citing the Associate Press confirmation that I was, and I quote, “correct.”